Hysteroscopy vs HSG or saline scan: which test checks what, with a consultation in Panjim
Medically reviewed by our consultant obstetrician & gynaecologist (MBBS, MS OBG). Last reviewed: 18 November 2026.
An HSG, a saline scan and a hysteroscopy answer different questions. The HSG is an X-ray dye test that mainly checks if the fallopian tubes are open. The saline scan is an ultrasound that outlines the womb cavity. A hysteroscopy looks inside the cavity directly and can often treat what it finds. A Panjim consult picks the right one.
Doctor available at: Vasco · Margao · Panjim · Mapusa
Women trying for a baby, or with bleeding that needs a reason, are often told they need "a test of the womb". Then a friend mentions the tube test, a report says saline sonography, and a third person talks about a telescope. This guide by the Pai Hospital Team lays the three tests next to each other: what each one sees, what it misses, what it feels like, and why one is picked over another. It is general information; the choice for you is made after your own history and scan are reviewed.
What does each of the three tests look at?
The womb has a hollow inside, the cavity, lined by the endometrium. From its two upper corners the fallopian tubes run out towards the ovaries. Problems can sit in the cavity (polyp, inward-bulging fibroid, septum, scar bands) or in the tubes (a block, swelling with fluid). No single test is perfect for both places, which is why the choice matters.
- HSG (hysterosalpingography): contrast dye goes in through the cervix while X-ray pictures are taken. The dye draws a silhouette of the cavity and then, if the tubes are open, travels through them and escapes from the far tips. Its main strength is the tubes.
- Saline scan (saline infusion sonography, also called sonohysterography or SIS): sterile salt water is trickled into the cavity through a fine tube during a vaginal ultrasound. The fluid parts the front and back walls, so a polyp or a fibroid pushing into the cavity stands out clearly. Its main strength is the cavity.
- Hysteroscopy: a slim camera-tipped telescope goes in through the cervix, and the inside of the womb is seen on a screen in real colour. The doctor sees the lining itself, not a shadow of it, and fine instruments can remove or cut a lesion during that same procedure.
Hysteroscopy vs HSG: which one checks the tubes?
This is the most common mix-up. An HSG shows whether dye passes through each tube, so it is the usual first look at the tubes in a fertility work-up. A hysteroscopy sees only the small openings where the tubes join the cavity; it cannot show whether the rest of each tube is open. To see the tubes along their whole length and the womb's outer surface, a laparoscopy is added, and the two are then done together. Read why a hysteroscopy and a laparoscopy are sometimes combined.
The reverse also holds. An HSG can hint that something is in the cavity, as a gap in the dye, but a small polyp may hide in the dye pool, and a blob of mucus or an air bubble can look like a lesion. The X-ray test is described step by step on our HSG tube test in Goa page.
Where does the saline scan fit?
The saline scan sits between the two. It needs no X-ray and no anaesthesia, and it gives a far sharper picture of the cavity than a plain ultrasound. It is often used when a routine scan shows a thickened or uneven lining and the doctor wants to know whether a polyp or fibroid sits within the cavity, and how far a fibroid reaches into it. A variant uses a foam or tiny bubbles instead of plain saline so that flow through the tubes can be watched on ultrasound; where that version is available, the doctor advises whether it suits you.
What the saline scan cannot do is treat. If it finds a polyp, removing it still needs a hysteroscopy.
How does each test feel?
- HSG: most women describe period-like cramps while the dye goes in, which tend to fade over the following minutes or hours. If a tube is blocked, the pressure can make the cramp stronger for a short while. Light spotting for a day is common.
- Saline scan: it feels like a vaginal scan with a short cramp as the fluid enters. Many women return to normal work the same day.
- Hysteroscopy: at Pai Hospital it is done in the operation theatre at Vaddem, Vasco, usually under a short anaesthesia, so you are not aware of the procedure. Mild cramps and light spotting in the next day or two are expected.
Pain thresholds differ; the team explains what to expect and which pain relief can be taken beforehand.
When in the cycle are the tests done, and what are the precautions?
All three are booked once the period's bleeding has ended and before an egg is released. The lining is thinner then, so the view is clearer, and the timing avoids testing during an early, still-unknown pregnancy. A pregnancy test may be asked for on the day.
- None of the tests is done during an active pelvic infection; a high-risk history may mean antibiotics are given first.
- Tell the team about any allergy to X-ray contrast or iodine before an HSG.
- For the hysteroscopy under anaesthesia, fasting instructions and the day's timings are given in advance.
Which test is usually chosen first?
There is no fixed order; it follows the question being asked.
- "Are my tubes open?" - often an HSG, for example before IUI. If the tubes and the cavity both need a direct look, a combined hysterolaparoscopy may be planned instead.
- "Why is the lining thick, or why is there bleeding between periods?" - often a saline scan or a hysteroscopy. When the scan already shows a polyp, going straight to hysteroscopy can find and remove it in one step.
- "Why did my periods become scanty after a D&C?" - scarring is suspected, and hysteroscopy confirms and treats it. Read about Asherman's syndrome and its hysteroscopic treatment.
- "Is the cavity ready before an embryo transfer?" - a saline scan or a hysteroscopy, depending on earlier findings.
Sometimes one test leads to another: an HSG with an odd cavity outline, or a saline scan showing a polyp, is followed by a hysteroscopy to see and treat it. The full procedure day is described on our hysteroscopy in Goa page.
What do the reports mean in plain words?
- HSG "bilateral free spill": dye came out of both tubes, so both are open on that day. "No spill" on one side can mean a true block or a tube that went into brief spasm; the doctor decides whether a repeat or a different test is needed.
- Saline scan "filling defect" or "echogenic focal lesion": something occupies part of the cavity, most often a polyp or a fibroid. The size and where it attaches guide the next step.
- Hysteroscopy note: it describes what was seen and what was done, and whether tissue was sent to the laboratory. A biopsy result follows a few days later.
Starting from Panjim: what happens next?
Women and couples from Panjim, Porvorim, Ribandar and the Mandovi side can first meet the doctor at our Panjim consultation point. That visit is for listening and planning: the history of periods and pregnancies, a look through past scans and reports, and a decision on which of the three tests answers your question. An HSG or a saline scan is then arranged and the report is reviewed with you, either back in Panjim or at Vasco. Should a hysteroscopy be advised, it is performed at Pai Hospital, Vaddem, Vasco-da-Gama, never at the consultation point, and the review afterwards can be held again in Panjim. The gynaecologist in Panjim page sets out how appointments and the trip south to Vasco are planned.
Bring any old HSG films or CDs, scan reports and discharge notes from earlier procedures. They often spare you a repeat test.
Your questions
Is a hysteroscopy better than an HSG?
Neither is better in general; they look at different things. An HSG tells whether the tubes are open, and gives a rough outline of the cavity. A hysteroscopy shows the inside of the womb directly and can treat a polyp or scar bands at once, but it does not show whether the tubes are open along their length.
Can a saline scan replace an HSG?
For the cavity, a saline scan usually gives the clearer picture. For the tubes, plain saline gives little information; a bubble or foam version, where available, can show tubal flow on ultrasound; your doctor will say whether an HSG is still needed.
Which of the three tests is the least uncomfortable?
The saline scan usually causes the least discomfort, often just a short cramp. An HSG brings period-like cramps that usually fade later the same day. A hysteroscopy at Pai Hospital is normally done under a short anaesthesia, so the procedure itself is not felt, though mild cramps can follow.
Do I need all three tests?
Most women do not. The doctor picks the test that answers your question. A second test is added only when the first one leaves a doubt or finds something that needs treatment, such as a polyp that a hysteroscopy can remove.
Can I have these tests if I might be pregnant?
No. All three are booked for the days once bleeding stops and before the egg is released, and a pregnancy test may be done on the day. Please tell the team if your period is late or if you may have conceived in that cycle.
I live in Panjim. Where is each test done?
The first consultation can be held at our Panjim consultation point, where the right test is chosen. The HSG or saline scan is arranged by the doctor and the report is reviewed with you. Any hysteroscopy is performed at Pai Hospital, Vaddem, Vasco-da-Gama.
Or call +91 95459 20817 · +91 75582 52088 · 0832 251 3641
This page is for general education and is not personal medical advice. Treatment depends on your own examination and reports, so please speak to a doctor about your situation. We do not carry out or offer sex determination of any kind.